21 October 2023
Dear friends
My puny efforts to get passenger trains and stations reinstated on 38 miles of existing, double track rail lines in Birmingham and the Black Country. Some, such as the Stourbridge, Dudley, Walsall rail line has its middle section reserved for trams that forever prevent passenger trains returning.
21 October 2023
Dear friends
BCWanderer is correct. Peter Madeley has done a brilliant job in uncovering this financial scandal. I have uncovered how Mayor Andy has allowed the development of the region's railways for TRAMS and a MUWAY of all things!! Two former mainline railways have been used for trams when, at a fraction of the price, both could have had their commuter, regional and even freight trains back at a fraction of the cost now squandered on Metro trams.
The UK's major, 22 Kms Black Country Cycle-Walk Mudway is on two former railway lines too but, unbelievably, Andy and the authorities cannot even do that job correctly and their incompetence has turned sections in all three council areas into impassable mud!!
Andy said "All three projects are full steam ahead" 25 July 2023
On Radio WM, on Kath's 10 am Show, Andy said:
"You are not right in saying that they were suspended ... it is bad that Pipers Row extension is late but we are testing trams on that. It will open very soon now subject to the testing ... WBHE has definitely never been suspended."
TIM WELLER This is incorrect. In the early summer of 2022, the whole WBHE had to be stopped because of a shortfall of money to finish it. It was therefore split into two phases. That means it WAS suspended. "WBHE Phase 2 now has the funding for the tram from Dudley to Merry Hill, so construction will go ahead ... All three projects are full steam ahead."
TIM WELLER The full WBHE was to terminate at Cottage St, Brierley Hill, not at Merry Hill and where is the new termination, at the shopping centre? WBHE is curtailed and cannot be completed because of its enormous cost. Andy failed to make that clear on the radio on 25 July. He hid embarrassing failings by the Combined Authority that the Express and Star uncovered, as here: See https://www.
What astonishes me is the obvious inappropriateness of reacting to a terrorist attack by declaring total war on the country that elected the terrorist group in 2007. But did they know how they would turn out? And, anyway, Hamas provides education, health, and other essential services for the Gazans. Israel knows that the vast majority of the people they slaughter will have not wanted anything to do with the Hamas attack on 7 October. Yet, Israel's government has killed nearly all non-combatants. 7,000 Gazans in the first 3 weeks.
Should the people of Israel be doing some self-examination over anything that they might have missed in 75 years?
Thanks, Chris. All good stuff. My own transport action is this:
Ten days and nine nights, with four nights in four different hotels. Never before so many hotel visits! I'm weakening. Kirkstyle Hotel, Biggar; the Philipburn Hotel, Selkirk; Buccleuch Arms Hotel, Moffat and, Westmorland Hotel, Tebay.
21 Donald summits visited and two full days exploring Selkirk for the first time. Next day, the full Borders Railway and the tram to Newhaven and the Granton Harbour E breakwater. Their tram is more comfortable and, leather seats on this year's new extension - unlike our own deceptive-looking 'sponge' which gives you a rude awakening as one's bum hits the hard plastic seat beneath a thin layer of cotton that is the non-existent 'sponge'!
Cold weather worsened by constant N or E winds but not a drop of rain. One night of very hard frost inside the car windows. Waterproofs needed for warmth, only.
One accident when I tripped and hit my left knee coming down a stony track from the bothy alongside Games Hope Burn. My right leg was weak and uncomfortable at times and that slowed me, along with general old age. I went with my right leg not quite right but not serious enough to see a doctor.
HIGHLIGHT
Carrifran Gans must be the steepest major hill in Scotland where the one direct path to the summit starts from a road. The hill is above Moffat Water, at a height of 757 m for the cairn from the cattle grid on the road at 192 m. You climb 565 m in 2 Kms of horizontal distance. Therefore, 28% average steepness from road to cairn, with slopes of 60-80%. On the descent, it was the nearest thing I've got to via ferrata, with my hanging on to the barbed wire free but, metal fence, on my left.
How is it that the West's 'truth' finds it perfectly acceptable to do to the Palestinians what their 'government', Hamas, did to our side on the 7 October? And, "for up to 3 months", too!
It is a most cruel and disproportionate form of revenge for Israel to spend 3 months demolishing the homes of Palestinians in Gaza with families still inside them. Especially when none of them had anything to do with the October 7 atrocity and, anyway wanted no one hurt in this way or, any other way.
Dear John PenroseI am writing to express my concern about the situation in Israel/Palestine and the UKs public and political response to it.What Hamas did in its attacks on October 7th was barbaric and cannot be defended. The attacks from motorbikes, the killing of children and taking of hostages is a crime against humanity. Of course, after 75 catastrophic years we may understand it, but such random killing cannot be justified.I have heard many times the statement Israel has the right to defend itself. That statement cannot be used to justify the collective punishment that the Israelis are now inflicting on the Palestinians of Gaza.Israel is practising its own form of apartheid. How many Palestinians have been killed by Israel in 2023? How many of these were children? How many Palestinians are being held in Israeli jails without trial? How many Palestinian homes, and villages have set on fire by Israeli settlers? What are the British governments official figures please?I am disappointed to see the prime minster and the leaders of the opposition so openly siding with Israel. The Hamas killings cannot be justified. The Israeli killings cannot be justified.It is time for British politicians to speak out against the violent terror that is being inflicted on the Palestinians by Israel, as well as speaking out against the violence of Hamas.Dear TimThanks for copying me in to your letter, I share your concerns. Above is my letter to my MP. I intend to send him another one this week.Hope you and Linda are both well.Best wishesAndyGet Outlook for iOSFrom: Tim Weller <timweller1@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, October 23, 2023 10:51:53 AM
To: James Morris <james.morris.mp@parliament.uk>
Subject: The ongoing slaughter of Gazans - for 3 months - by our side is unacceptableTO OUR FAITH LEADERS - and my MP Will anyone else speak up?When will other ordinary, decent people break their guilty silence and condemn brutal, barbaric Benjamin sending other ordinary, decent people to the most horrific deaths when they have nothing to do with Hamas and have never hurt anyone in their entire lives?When will our Jewish, Christian and Muslim leaders outrightly condemn this obvious immorality and murder of babies and the elderly stuck in their care homes and shattered hospitals unable to escape the Israeli reign of terror?Using terror to defeat terror is NOT a noble and decent act. Nor is it effective. It simply ups the anti and escalates the hatred, as our side has discovered over the last 75 years of Israel being born out of violence and killings in 1948.This indiscriminate slaughter of wholly innocent men, women and children breaks every moral code in the book, including the Koran and the Bible that also contains the Hebrew Scriptures.I understand, some Hamas fighters were killed on 7 October, the day of the Hamas atrocity in Israel.It is what Russia is doing in Ukraine and what our side is doing in Yemen and has done in countless other countries since the 2nd WW.BUT THAT IS NO EXCUSE for Benjamin Netanyahu to follow our shameful and immoral example.Tim Weller
On a more serious and desperately horrifying note:- From the days of that giant Goliath, off and on, the people of Gaza and the people of Israel have been at each others throats. One Lord Jesus lived and taught forgiveness, mercy and nonviolence for all peoples. But one barbaric Benjamin, over all Israel, does not practise an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth but a revenge of collective punishment.
Perpetual impertinence and, preposterous to have a just God on one side only! Thus, the other side can be wiped out. So Allah is Great as equally as our God is even Greater and can do Anything!
The limitations of military action
Military action cannot be proportionate to the threat that you face.
Hamas must be destroyed said Tom Tugendhat, Security Minister. He said it is a vicious terrorist organisation, and its total destruction would be a blessing for both Israel and the Palestinian people.
Israel has to sort out how to live in peace with its neighbours. It has never done that for 75 years. 75 years of a firm belief in coercion, imposition, force, violence and killings to live in uneasy 'peace'.
I disagree with their policy which is this:
LOVE LETTER TO COUNCILLORS ON A MISSION FOR TRAMS TO MERRY HILL
I'm so pleased for you that you have your long-awaited (from the 1980s) Metro trams at long last. But, don't rest on your laurels; there is still very MUCH more to do, my friends!
I quite understand that you must continue your 60-year-old policy of destroying, this time, Dudley's very last railway, to relegate our town from having back the mainline Castle Hill Railway Station to, instead, a piddling little tram stop and test track. Dudley's New Fame:- the largest town in the UK by population without a railway station. Yet, the line was successful for 100 years until we all fell in love with cars. And, to this day, nearly 50 Kms, already built, are left with nothing!
What is your personal wish for the former mainline railway and existing freight line from Stourbridge Jct to Brierley Hill and, the mothballed, former passenger and freight railway from Wednesbury to Burton on Trent? Nearly 50 Kms still wasted alongside or near to congested main roads and motorways. It has every motorway, road and canal crossing already built but you good politicians forgot to finish the job - with, you know what!
What are you doing to respond to your own Council's Climate Emergency motion that you passed in 2020 and then passed over ever since?
Why did you bring it forward when it does look, so far, as though you have every intention to change nothing? You now lay yourselves open to the charge of hypocrisy, of course.
Have you ever considered reforming your actions to ones of retrenchment? Retrenchment to minimise deadly greenhouse gas emissions and to maximise economic growth in insulation, Passivhaus standards in housing, solar PV on every E, W, S roof and small to medium-sized, highly energy-efficient homes for the homeless and badly housed?
Have you ever considered the carrot, the reward of regional Fare-Free Public Transport that old crocks like me have had for 15 years, so far? This OAP and friends in Brum are championing the same perk for you youngsters! Campaign with us over this iniquitous inequality and blatant discrimination against the young and middle-aged. Co-operation and partnership working, please.
Remember, too the UK's major, urban-rural-urban, 25 Kms, business, commuter and leisure route that is the fine, the upstanding, the disgraceful Black Country Cycle-Walk Mudway through four nature reserves and one Woodland Trust property.
And a decent mosque for Dudley town Muslims. Stop that discrimination and Islamophobia.
And a cycle-walkway on the other side of Duncan Edwards Way from the tramline.
"When in a hole stop digging! Today global economic growth is averaging 3% and has done so for 60 years. This doubles the global economy over 20 years. This is incompatible with the natural limits of the planet and will lead to the breakdown of its ecosystems. Degrowth offers a strategic alternative to such growth and the conflicts and societal breakdowns that it is already generating.
"Alan Thornett is the author of "Facing the Apocalypse - Arguments for Ecosocialism", and has recently written this article for the Green Left's publication Watermelon."
https://www.ecosocialistdiscussion.com/2023/09/16/degrowth-a-remarkable-renaissance/
Dear Bridget
"Man has lost the capacity to foresee and to forestall, (so) he will end by destroying the world."
(Albert Schweitzer, 1950s, cited in "Silent Spring" by Rachel Carson, 1962). My view: the world will blissfully go on without its full burden of 7 billion humans - and rising!
THE ESSENCE OF WHY THE BLACK COUNTRY RAILWAY MUST BE FINISHED:
GLORIOUS ENGLISH ECCENTRICITY: the UK's only mothballed, easily reinstated, ready made but they forgot the trains and stations, mainline railway. Nothing to do with the EU. Their mainland railways are better and actually used for TRAINS!
WHICH IS MORE SENSIBLE THINKING?
2 or 3 fast regional trains every hour and nine new stations to complete the 120 Kms between Worcester and Derby; OR: 6 to 10 "bus on rails" trams every hour and 17 tram stops over only 11 Kms to STOP the reinstatement of the railway "of national strategic significance."
SMART POLITICIANS?
£449 m plus cost overruns to build the Black Country Tramline over 6.7 Kms that destroys the Black Country Railway over 56 Kms. All 56 Kms can get commuter/regional trains back for less than £200 m (2015 figure). Or, stupid politicians?
SMART RAILWAYS?
Why CUT a 120 Kms principal, mainline railway through the congested West Midlands with a tramline in two halves, a railway test track and a trail of trees, Japanese knotweed and undergrowth, when absent trains on 56 Kms of track could have their trains and stations back, FOR LESS MONEY than using trams on only 6.7 Kms?
The nonsense of High Scam 2 with no stations, for people who don't fly, to get on and off the thing! MORE DETAIL: Two terminal stations, two stations that some trains get diverted to (Brum and Crewe) and two airports, ONLY.
Extra provision and capacity for flyers, only! No-one else.
Dear Top Officials at WMCA