The U.K. Green Party's adoption of a highly controversial policy that defines Zionism as a "racist ideology" raises questions over the wider future for not only the party's Jewish members but also for it as a political movement seeking to broaden its electoral support.
The motion passed 1,022-813 at the party's annual conference in Brighton on Sunday, formally making it party policy to classify Zionism as an "ethnonationalist political project" and treat it like any other form of racism.
The policy calls for the establishment of a "single democratic Palestinian State in all of historic Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital," with the right of return for Palestinian refugees and their descendants. The party also recognizes what the motion describes as the Palestinian people's right to resist occupation "by all available means under international law."
Jewish organizations roundly condemned the decision, while four of the party's five MPs publicly opposed the motion.
Polling consistently finds that the majority of the Jewish community in the United Kingdom considers themselves to be Zionist. In 2024, research by the London-based Institute for Jewish Policy Research found that 65 percent of British Jews identified as Zionists. However, a survey conducted by Jewish members of the Green Party found that 81 percent of 108 Jewish people within the party who responded described themselves as non-Zionist or anti-Zionist, while 19 percent identified as Zionist. The results were published last Thursday, ahead of the Brighton conference.
The dispute over the motion had been brewing for months before the conference. Jewish Greens, a group within the party providing a voice for Jewish people, raised concerns back in January, warning those proposing the motion that if it was adopted, they would face an "almost universally hostile response" from Jews within the party. They asked the Greens for Palestine lobby group that was behind the motion for clarification over whether it was intended to ban Zionists from the party or subject them to disciplinary action.
They also asked what exactly support for "the struggle to achieve liberation" meant, noting in an email that "we are talking specifically about a political context where a significant portion of political actors, including Hamas and PIJ [Palestinian Islamic Jihad] are committed to using violence against civilians as a methodology of resistance."
The dialogue between the Jewish members of the party and the activists behind the motion subsequently deteriorated, as seen in publicly available emails between the groups. By March, Jewish Greens were proposing formal mediation to "re-open communication and to try to repair the relationship." However, Greens For Palestine refused and conditioned mediation on having Jewish Greens issue a public apology to them and the wider party. They accused them of briefing the right-wing media, the Israeli Embassy in the U.K. and British counter-terrorism police against them, and insisted that they liberate their minds "from the supremacist grip of Zionism."
Greens For Palestine did not respond to a request for comment.
No comments:
Post a Comment